196 Beach 92nd St, Rockaway Park, NY 11693
Order now
Top dishes
Malted Chocolate Chip Cookie
Chocolate chip cookie meets everyone's favorite classic drink - a malt! Nutty barley comes through and provides a rich sweetness to everyone's favorite cookie.
Eggnog Snickerdoodle
A classic cookie meets a classic holiday drink. Rich buttery cookie and eggnog with nutmeg make this a new Christmas favorite. They won't be here long!
Iced Oatmeal
A classic cookie, kept classic. Memories of waking up at grandma's house to fresh baked cookies aren't too far away once you take a bite.
Black and White
New York's favorite cookie (or is it a cake?) However you split it, everybody wins with sweet vanilla and rich chocolate icing.
Candy Bar Cookie
Our newest cookie, loaded with Snickers, Twix, 3 Musketeers, and Milky Way Bars. Yum!
Customer service was exemplary. Pies were yummy. We ordered the small Apple Dulce de Leche, they were out of that size and replaced it with the large at no additional charge. Holidays are coming, and we now have a go to bakery.
Whether you're craving a quick bite or looking to treat yourself to a delicious meal, you can now order your The Fat Cardinal Bakery favorites for takeout or delivery.